I thought this was so charming, it wasn't OMG to die for but still i read it with a certain warmth . I was really captivated with the heroine , i just loved her strength . My only problem with the heroine is that even though she needed advice, she went and told her two friends his whole problem which was a sensitive issue from what i saw and i thought she dealt with that in the wrong way . I have seen countless heroines not directly talk about the issue and got advice from their friends . That should have been handled better IMO . I just felt she should have had ingrained loyalty to his secrets even though he messed up.Aside from that the book was good and i enjoyed itTheir bond was so emotional and never ending and i really liked that. If you need a book in between sad books this would be it even it has a fairly heavy topic .How they got back together was sweet .